A comparative evaluation of design factors on bubble column operation in photosynthetic biogas upgrading

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 Environmental Research Institute, MaREI Centre, University College Cork, Cork, Ireland.

2 School of Engineering, University College Cork, Cork, Ireland.

Abstract

Studies attempting to optimise photosynthetic biogas upgrading by simultaneous investigation of the bubble column-photobioreactor setup have experienced considerable variability in results and conclusions. To identify the sources of such variation, this work quantitatively compared seven design factors (superficial gas velocity; liquid to gas flow rate (L/G) ratio; empty bed residence time; liquid inlet pH; liquid inlet alkalinity; temperature; and algal concentration) using the L16 Taguchi orthogonal array as a screening design of experiment. Assessments were performed using the signal to noise (S/N) ratio on the performance of CO2 removal (CO­2 removal efficiency, CO2 absorption rate, and overall CO2 mass transfer coefficient) and O2 stripping (O2 concentration in biomethane and O2 flow rate in biomethane). Results showed that pH and L/G ratio were the most critical design factors. Temperature and gas residence times had minimal impact on the biomethane composition.  The interactive effect between pH and L/G ratio was the most impactful, followed by the interactive effects between superficial gas velocity and L/G ratio and pH on CO2 removal efficiency. The impact of L/G ratio, algal concentration, and pH (in that order of impact) caused up to a 90% variation in oxygen content in biomethane. However, algal concentration had a diminishing role as the L/G ratio increased. Using only the statistically significant main effects and interactions, the biomethane composition (CO2% and O2%) was predicted with over 95% confidence through regression equations for superficial gas velocity up to 0.2 cm/s.

Graphical Abstract

A comparative evaluation of design factors on bubble column operation in photosynthetic biogas upgrading

Highlights

  • Multiple factors and their interaction influence photosynthetic biogas upgrading.
  • pH and liquid to gas flow (L/G) ratio affect CO2 removal the most.  
  • Interaction between pH and L/G ratio has the highest influence on CO2 removal. 
  • L/G ratio, followed by algal concentration has the highest influence on O2 stripping.
  • Bubble column operation predicted to produce grid quality biomethane.

Keywords

References

[1] American Public Health Association (APHA), 1992. APHA Method 2320, in: standard methods for the examination of water and wastewater. American Public Health Association (APHA), Washington, DC.
[2] Angelidaki, I., Treu, L., Tsapekos, P., Luo, G., Campanaro, S., Wenzel, H., Kougias, P.G., 2018. Biogas upgrading and utilization: current status and perspectives. Biotechnol. Adv. 36(2), 452-466.
[3] Antony, J., 2014. 4 - A systematic methodology for design of experiments, 2nd ed. Des. Exp. Eng. Sci. 33-50.
[4] Awty-carroll, D., Ravella, S., Clifton-brown, J., Robson, P., 2020. Using a Taguchi DOE to investigate factors and interactions affecting germination in Miscanthus sinensis. Sci. Rep. 10(1), 1-11.
[5] Bahr, M., Díaz, I., Dominguez, A., González Sánchez, A., Muñoz, R., 2014. Microalgal-biotechnology as a platform for an integral biogas upgrading and nutrient removal from anaerobic effluents. Environ. Sci. Technol. 48(1), 573-581.
[6] Barros, A.I., Gonçalves, A.L., Simões, M., Pires, J.C., 2015. Harvesting techniques applied to microalgae : a review. Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev. 41, 1489-1500.
[7] Binaghi, L., Del Borghi, A., Lodi, A., Converti, A., Del Borghi, M., 2003. Batch and fed-batch uptake of carbon dioxide by Spirulina platensis. Process Biochem. 38(9), 1341-1346.
[8] Borhani, T.N.G., Azarpour, A., Akbari, V., Alwi, S.R.W., Manan, Z.A., 2015. CO2 capture with potassium carbonate solutions: a state-of-the-art review. Int. J. Greenhouse Gas Control. 41, 142-162.
[9] Bose, A., Lin, R., Rajendran, K., Xia, A., O’Shea, R., Murphy, J.D., 2019. How to optimize photosynthetic biogas upgrading: a perspective on system design and microalgae selection. Biotechnol. Adv. 37(8), 107444.
[10] Bose, A., O’Shea, R., Lin, R., Murphy, J.D., 2020. A perspective on novel cascading algal biomethane biorefinery systems. Bioresour. Technol. 304, 123027.
[11] Bose, A., O’Shea, R., Lin, R., Murphy, J.D., 2021. Design, commissioning and performance assessment of a lab-scale bubble column reactor for photosynthetic biogas upgrading with Spirulina platensis. Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 60(15), 5688–5704.
[12] Chen, P.C., Huang, C.H., Su, T., Chen, H.W., Yang, M.W, Tsao, J.M., 2015. Optimum conditions for the capture of carbon dioxide with a bubble-column scrubber. Int. J. Greenhouse Gas Control. 35, 47-55.
[13] Chen, P.C., Lin, S., 2018. Optimization in the absorption and desorption of CO2 using sodium glycinate solution. Appl. Sci. 8(11), 2041.
[14] Chiranjeevi, P., Mohan, S.V., 2016. Critical parametric influence on microalgae cultivation towards maximizing biomass growth with simultaneous lipid productivity. Renewable Energy. 98, 64-71.
[15] Clark, K.N., 1990. The effect of high pressure and temperature on phase distributions in a bubble column. Chem. Eng. Sci. 45(8), 2301-2307.
[16] Costa, J.A.V., Colla, L.M., Duarte Filho, P., 2003. Spirulina platensis growth in open raceway ponds using fresh water supplemented with carbon, nitrogen and metal ions. Z. Naturforsch. C. 58(1-2), 76-80.
[17] Davis, R., John, P., 2018. Application of Taguchi-Based Design of Experiments for Industrial Chemical Processes, in: Silva, V. (Ed.), Statistical Approaches With Emphasis on Design of Experiments Applied to Chemical Processes Montgomery. IntechOpen.
[18] Deckwer, W.D., Louisi, Y., Zaidi, A., Ralek, M., 1980. Hydrodynamic properties of the fischer-tropsch slurry process. Ind. Eng. Chem. Process Des. Dev. 19(4), 699-708.
[19] del Rosario Rodero, M., Carvajal, A., Castro, V., Navia, D., de Prada, C., Lebrero, R., Muñoz, R., 2019a. Development of a control strategy to cope with biogas flowrate variations during photosynthetic biogas upgrading. Biomass Bioenergy. 131, 105414.
[20] del Rosario Rodero, M., Lebrero, R., Serrano, E., Lara, E., Arbib, Z., García-Encina, P.A., Muñoz, R., 2019b. Technology validation of photosynthetic biogas upgrading in a semi- industrial scale algal-bacterial photobioreactor. Bioresour. Technol. 279, 43-49.
[21] del Rosario Rodero, M., Carvajal, A., Arbib, Z., Lara, E., de Prada, C., Lebrero, R., Muñoz, R., 2020a. Performance evaluation of a control strategy for photosynthetic biogas upgrading in a semi-industrial scale photobioreactor. Bioresour. Technol. 307, 123207.
[22] del Rosario Rodero, M., Severi, C.A., Rocher-Rivas, R., Quijano, G., Muñoz, R., 2020b. Long-term influence of high alkalinity on the performance of photosynthetic biogas upgrading. Fuel. 281, 118804.
[23] del Rosario Rodero, M., Posadas, E., Toledo-Cervantes, A., Lebrero, R., Muñoz, R., 2018. Influence of alkalinity and temperature on photosynthetic biogas upgrading efficiency in high rate algal ponds. Algal Res. 33, 284-290.
[24] De Oliveira, M.A.C.L. Monteiro, M.P.C., Robbs, P.G., Leite, S.G.F., 1999. Growth and chemical composition of Spirulina maxima and Spirulina platensis biomass at different temperatures. Aquacult. Int. 7(4), 261-275.
[25] Fernández, I., Guzmán, J.L., Berenguel, M., Acién, F.G., 2017. Dynamic modeling of microalgal production in photobioreactors, in: tripathi, Bhumi Nath, Kumar, D. (Eds.), Prospects and Challenges in Algal Biotechnology. Springer, pp. 49-86.
[26] Franco-Morgado, M., Alcántara, C., Noyola, A., Muñoz, R., González-Sánchez, A., 2017. A study of photosynthetic biogas upgrading based on a high rate algal pond under alkaline conditions: influence of the illumination regime. Sci. Total Environ. 592, 419-425.
[27] Ganapathy, T., Murugesan, K.A., Gakkhar, R.P., 2009. Performance optimization of Jatropha biodiesel engine model using Taguchi approach. Appl. Energy. 86(11), 2476-2486.
[28] Gas Networks Ireland, 2018. Code of Operations, Part G.
[29] Hikita, H., Asai, S., Takatsuka, T., 1976. Absorption of carbon dioxide into aqueous sodium hydroxide and sodium carbonate-bicarbonate solutions. Chem. Eng. J. 11(2), 131-141.
[30] Hu, G., Nicholas, N.J., Smith, K.H., Mumford, K.A., Kentish, S.E., Stevens, G.W., 2016. Carbon dioxide absorption into promoted potassium carbonate solutions: a review. Int. J. Greenhouse Gas Control. 53, 28-40.
[31] Hu, Q., Guterman, H., Richmond, A., 1996. A flat inclined modular photobioreactor for outdoor mass cultivation of photoautotrophs. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 51(1), 51-60.
[32] Huang, Q., Jiang, F., Wang, L., Yang, C., 2017. Design of photobioreactors for mass cultivation of photosynthetic organisms. Engineering. 3(3), 318-329.
[33] Jakobsen, H.A., 2009. Bubble Column Reactors, in: Chemical Reactor Modeling, Multiphase Reactive Flows. Springer Berlin Heidelberg, Trondheim, pp. 335-501.
[34] Jones, B., 2016. 21st century screening experiments: what, why, and how. Qual. Eng. 28(1), 98-106.
[35] Kaye, G. W.C., Laby, T.H., 1986. Tables of physical and chemical constants and some mathematical functions, 15th Ed. London, New York, Longman.
[36] Kim, H.Y., 2017. Statistical notes for clinical researchers: chi-squared test and Fisher’s exact test. Restor. Dent. Endod. 42(2), 152.
[37] Kishore, R.A., Kumar, P., Priya, S., 2018. A comprehensive optimization study on Bi2 Te3 -based thermoelectric generators using the Taguchi method. Sust. Energy Fuels. 2(1), 175-190.
[38] Kitchin, J., 1994. 6 - Basic statistical inference, in: dunning, F.B. (Ed.), Methods in Experimental Physics. Elsevier Masson SAS, Houston, Texas, pp. 28, 155-186.
[39] Knuutila, H., Juliussen, O., Svendsen, H.F., 2010. Kinetics of the reaction of carbon dioxide with aqueous sodium and potassium carbonate solutions. Chem. Eng. Sci. 65(23), 6077-6088.
[40] Krishnaiah, K., Shahabudeen, P., 2012. Applied Design of Experiments and Taguchi Methods. PHI Learning Private Limited, New Delhi.
[41] Kulkarni, A.A., Joshi, J.B., 2005. Bubble formation and bubble rise velocity in gas - liquid systems : a review. Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 44(16), 5873-5931.
[42] Madkour, F.F., Kamil, A.E.W., Nasr, H.S., 2012. Production and nutritive value of Spirulina platensis in reduced cost media. Egypt. J. Aquat. Res. 38(1), 51-57.
[43] Marín, D., Carmona-Martínez, A.A., Blanco, S., Lebrero, R., Muñoz, R., 2021. Innovative operational strategies in photosynthetic biogas upgrading in an outdoors pilot scale algal-bacterial photobioreactor. Chemosphere. 264(1), 128470.
[44] Marín, D., Posadas, E., Cano, P., Pérez, V., Blanco, S., Lebrero, R., Muñoz, R., 2018. Seasonal variation of biogas upgrading coupled with digestate treatment in an outdoors pilot scale algal-bacterial photobioreactor. Bioresour. Technol. 263, 58-66.
[45] Mehta, P.D., 2001. Control variable in research. Int. Encycl. Social Behav. Sci. 2727-2730.
[46] Meier, L., Barros, P., Torres, A., Vilchez, C., Jeison, D., 2017. Photosynthetic biogas upgrading using microalgae: effect of light/dark photoperiod. Renewable Energy. 106, 17-23.
[47] Meier, L., Martínez, C., Vílchez, C., Bernard, O., Jeison, D., 2019. Evaluation of the feasibility of photosynthetic biogas upgrading: Simulation of a large-scale system. Energy. 198, 116313.
[48] Meier, L., Pérez, R., Azócar, L., Rivas, M., Jeison, D., 2015. Photosynthetic CO2 uptake by microalgae: an attractive tool for biogas upgrading. Biomass Bioenergy. 73, 102-109.
[49] Mohsin, I., He, K., Li, Z., Zhang, F., Du, R., 2020. Optimization of the polishing efficiency and torque by using Taguchi method and ANOVA in robotic polishing. Appl. Sci. 10(3), 824.
[50] Molina, E., Ferna, J., Acie, F.G., Chisti, Y., 2001. Tubular photobioreactor design for algal cultures. J. Biotechnol. 92(2), 113-131.
[51] Montgomery, D.C., 2012. Design and Analysis of Experiments, 9th ed. John Wiley and Sons, Inc.
[52] Myers, R.H., Montgomery, D.C., Anderson-Cook, C.M., 2017. Response surface methodology: process and product optimization using designed experiments, 4th ed. John Wiley & Sons Inc, New Jersey.
[53] Posadas, E., del Mar Morales, M., Gomez, C., Acién, F.G., Muñoz, R., 2015a. Influence of pH and CO2 source on the performance of microalgae-based secondary domestic wastewater treatment in outdoors pilot raceways. Chem. Eng. J. 265, 239-248.
[54] Posadas, E., Serejo, M.L., Blanco, S., Pérez, R., García-Encina, P.A., Muñoz, R., 2015b. Minimization of biomethane oxygen concentration during biogas upgrading in algal-bacterial photobioreactors. Algal Res. 12, 221-229.
[55] Priyadarshi, D., Paul, K.K., 2019. Optimisation of biodiesel production using Taguchi model. Waste Biomass Valorization. 10(6), 1547-1559.
[56] Rajendran, K., O’Gallachoir, B., Murphy, J.D., 2019. The combined role of policy and incentives in promoting cost ef fi cient decarbonisation of energy : a case study for biomethane. J. Clean. Prod. 219, 278-290.
[57] Rao, R.S., Kumar, C.G., Prakasham, R.S., Hobbs, P.J., 2008. The Taguchi methodology as a statistical tool for biotechnological applications : a critical appraisal. Biotechnol. J. 3(4), 510-523.
[58] Roy, R.K., 2010. A primer on the Taguchi method, second edition. Society of Manufacturing Engineers.
[59] Shah, S.R., Parikh, R.H., Chavda, J.R., Sheth, N.R., 2013. Application of Plackett-Burman screening design for preparing glibenclamide nanoparticles for dissolution enhancement. Powder Technol. 235, 405-411.
[60] Singh, G., Patidar, S.K., 2018. Microalgae harvesting techniques: a review. J. Environ. Manage. 217, 499-508.
[61] Shaikh, A., Al-Dahhan, M., 2010. A new methodology for hydraulic similarity in bubble columns. Can. J. Chem. Eng. 88(4), 503-517.
[62] Smith, Z.D., Keller, J.R., Bello, M., Cordes, N.L., Welch, C.F., Torres, J.A., Goodwin, L.A., Pacheco, R.M., Sandoval, C.W., 2016. Plackett-Burman experimental design to facilitate syntactic foam development. J. Appl. Polym. Sci. 133(1).
[63] Sun, Z., Liu, J., Zhou, Z.G., 2016. Algae for biofuels: an emerging feedstock, in: Luque, R., Lin, C.S.K., Wilson, K., Clark, J. (Eds.), Handbook of Biofuels Production, 2nd ed. Elsevier, pp. 673-698.
[64] Toledo-Cervantes, A., Madrid-Chirinos, C., Cantera, S., Lebrero, R., Muñoz, R., 2017. Influence of the gas-liquid flow configuration in the absorption column on photosynthetic biogas upgrading in algal-bacterial photobioreactors. Bioresour. Technol. 225, 336-342.
[65] Vasumathi, K.K., Premalatha, M., Subramanian, P., 2012. Parameters influencing the design of photobioreactor for the growth of microalgae. Renew. Sust. Energy Rev. 16(7), 5443-5450.
[66] Wall, D.M., McDonagh, S., Murphy, J.D., 2017. Cascading biomethane energy systems for sustainable green gas production in a circular economy. Bioresour. Technol. 243, 1207-1215.
[67] Yang, J., Cui, X., Feng, Y., Jing, G., Kang, L., Luo, M., 2017. Experimental study on microalgae cultivation in novel photobioreactor of concentric double tubes with aeration pores along tube length direction. Int. J. Green Energy. 14(15), 1269-1276.
[68] Zedníková, M., Orvalho, S., Fialová, M., Ruzicka, M.C., 2018. Measurement of volumetric mass transfer coefficient in bubble columns. ChemEngineering 2(2), 19.

Files

Cited by

Share

How to cite

Statistics